Monday, September 28, 2009
Week 5: Chapter 5: Barbie vs. the Menstrual Kit (p. 167-201)
The focus of this article was the “girls’ movement” within feminism that focused on younger girls and the issues that they faced. The authors discuss a work titled: In a Different Voice by Carol Gilligan. Gilligan’s writing is a celebration of diverse experiences and “called for the appreciation of women’s voices, their different values and views” (p. 173). Approximately ten years later Gilligan started another work titled Making Connections. In this book she gave girls a voice by examining girls at a private school ranging from ages eleven to sixteen (previously a group that was not researched). Gilligan’s conclusion in both of these books was that women had to find their own voice and form strong relationships with other women starting from an early age.
Next, Baumgardner and Richards discuss another important figure in the girls’ movement, Nell Merlino. Merlino came up with the idea for “Take Our Daughters to Work Day” that was presented in the beginning of the chapter. This program was created to give girls a chance to see different kinds of working environments, especially if their own mother was not able to take them to work (for example, stay at home moms or women on welfare). The program was very successful and by 1999, fifty-six million adults and nineteen million girls had participated in the program. However, due to its immense success, not every program could be properly regulated. One issue within the girls’ movement is the portrayal of girls. The authors state that “The problem is not that we can’t simultaneously acknowledge girls’ strength and sexism; it is that girls are being labeled victims of society and, by implication, passive dupes whether or not they themselves feel this way” (p. 185). They also state that for future programs to be successful “We need to listen to girls instead of lecturing them” (p. 185).
Baumgardner and Richards discuss Barbie near the end of the chapter. They
begin by introducing the fact that “The literature of the girls’ movement might not be saying ‘you’re not thin enough or pretty enough,’ but it is saying ‘you’re not strong enough or confident enough’” (p. 191). Basically, girls are concerned with appearances and they should not be made to feel guilty for this reason. The title of the chapter comes from this section because the authors discuss “the menstrual kit” or the “first-blood ceremony.” This is supposed to be an empowering event, but it does not consider the girl’s point of view. They also provided an anecdote proving that the younger girls celebrating the ceremony often felt uncomfortable about it. This leads to the discussion of Barbie. Barbie has generally been viewed as very negative within the feminist movement. However, Baumgardner and Richards argue that girls do not always feel that they want to become Barbie, but often use the dolls to act out different scenarios and it really is not as negative an influence as everyone thinks. The authors do not dismiss Mattel though, and state that they have a responsibility to not give negative representations of women.
The concluding remarks of this chapter suggest that in order to improve girls’ self-esteem, and ultimately the women that they become, there needs to be a focus now on the younger generation. This needs to be accomplished by giving girls voice and the ability to make decisions.
Response:
I really enjoyed this chapter and I think that girls should be given voice within the feminist movement. This really was a difficult time of my life and I can only imagine how much it would have helped to have someone there to work through issues with me, especially if it was a group composed of my peers. I feel like adolescence can be a very isolating time and that by giving girls a support system it would ultimately help them to grow up and become well adjusted adults. I really feel like it would be best to stamp out self esteem issues immediately and give them the opportunity to really grow while they are still young. I think that this time period is also important when you consider identity. Overall, I thought the projects and programs presented in this chapter should be implemented on a larger scale.
Sunday, September 20, 2009
Week 4: Monique Wittig: One is Not Born a Woman (p. 265-271) and Elsa Barkley Brown: “What has Happened Here”(p. 272-287)
Summary:
Simone de Beauvoir said: “One is not born, but becomes a woman” (p. 265). Wittig states that there is no “natural woman” and that the idea of being feminine is created by society. She also notes that since a lesbian society does exist, this defeats the idea of “natural woman.” However, Wittig recognizes that many people still believe the oppression of women is “biological as well as historical” (p. 266). Wittig explains further that this could never be a lesbian approach to women’s oppression because it is based on the idea that the beginning of society is heterosexuality. Also, biology (or the capability of having children) is not enough to define Woman. Wittig also discusses the idea that sex is like race in the sense that it is visible and therefore seems to belong to some kind of natural order. This leads to the lesbian perspective that this perception of Woman is very “unnatural” because it was created and based before the women’s liberation movement. Wittig states: “To refuse to be a woman, however, does not mean that one has to become a man” (p. 267). Meaning, that refusing to “be a woman” is simply just refusing to accept imposed ideas of femininity. She also clarifies: “Thus a lesbian has to be something else, a not-woman, a not-man, a product of society, not a product of nature, for there is no nature is society” (p. 267). It is not enough to simply promote women (“woman is wonderful” concept); it is the idea of being a man or a woman “which are political categories and not natural givens” (p. 267) that needs to be rejected.
A materialist feminist approach sees women and men as separate classes. Therefore, the goal is “to suppress men as a class, not through a genocidal, but a political struggle” (p. 267). This means that if there was no longer a class called “men,” there would no longer be a class called “women.” The first step would be to dispel the myth of Woman. Wittig states that “‘woman’ is there to confuse us, to hide the reality ‘women’” (p. 268). She believes that the new focus would be on personal identity.
Wittig also presents a Marxist perspective. She states that Marxism lead to two results for women: the order of men and women was assumed to be natural and the conflict between men and women was hidden behind a “natural division of labor” (p. 270). Also, if women united it would threaten the strength of the people in a Marxist society.
Wittig concludes by calling attention again to the rejection of the myth of Woman. She believes that the categories of sex must be destroyed and that all sciences that use these definitions should also be rejected. She again comes back to the model of lesbianism; she states that this is the only category that goes beyond woman and man currently. So, in order to reject this myth of Woman we must destroy “heterosexuality as a social system which is based on the oppression of women by men and which produces the doctrine of the difference between the sexes to justify this oppression” (p. 271).
Response:
I thought this article was really clear in explaining the categories of sex. It seems to me that the categories presented by Wittig are Man, Woman, and Lesbian. However, Man and Woman are based on supposedly “natural” categories and need to be destroyed in order to eliminate this myth of Woman. I had never thought of lesbianism as a category comparable to the Man/Woman model, but it really makes sense. It rejects both categories of Man and Woman to create a new sexless category. I also really feel that by emulating this new category, it would destroy the Man/Woman model. Although, this is all theoretical, I think that if the heterosexual society model could be destroyed and a sexless system was created, then it would be much easier to stop the oppression to women.
Elsa Barkley Brown: “What has Happened Here” The Politics of Difference in Women’s History and Feminist Politics (p. 272-287)
Summary:
Brown introduces this article with the idea of diversity of women’s experiences and history. She suggests that others see highlighting differences within the women’s movement as counterproductive. However, she suggests that the underlying thinking behind women’s history and politics needs to be restructured to incorporate and celebrate diversity. Next, Brown discusses the problem of history by comparing it to jazz music. She states that jazz relies on improvisation and responding quickly to the music created by others in the group. In this way, everyone gets to play, but works together to create something unique. History should be looked at the same way because it is not a series of isolated events experienced by one person at a time. Instead, many people are experiencing the same event at the same time, but in potentially different ways. Brown also suggests that simply tying all women together with the word “gender” is equally limiting because all women do not share the exact same experience. She continues her explanation stating that acknowledging difference is not enough, we must also understand the “relational nature of those differences” (p. 275). She provides an example of women of color being exploited by multinational corporations who export jobs, which leads to higher unemployment for women of minorities and a growth in employment available to mostly white middle-class women. This split leads to different experiences amongst women. Brown also recognizes that most historians acknowledge differences and then ignore them, however, she states: “The effect of this is that acknowledging difference becomes a way of reinforcing the notion that the experiences of white middle-class women are the norm; all others become deviant—different from” (p. 276). Basically, by thinking this way, it is furthering the oppression of women because it assumes that the white woman is the standard. Brown continues: “We have still to recognize that all women do not have the same gender” (p. 276). She also explains that in women’s history being different means non-white and non-heterosexual, thus underlining the fact that this is the norm in our society and everything else is deviant or different. Also, this gives white heterosexual women privilege in the recording of women’s history.
Next, Brown discusses the case of Anita Hill in 1991. Hill was sexually harassed and became a “universal symbol, evidence of the common bonds of womanhood” (p. 278). However, her race was never addressed; her experience was simply reduced to the experience of a woman. Brown argues that in order to understand her experience, we must consider it from her perspective of not only being a woman, but also being “a young black woman, the daughter of Oklahoma farmers, whose family and community expected her to do well” (p. 278). Simply looking at her case from a woman’s perspective is not enough; it does not convey the uniqueness of her experience or represent the different pressures that she faced. Also, the stereotypes of African American women were not addressed or the fact that Hill was speaking against an African American man and potentially upsetting the entire African American community. Brown acknowledges that telling Hill’s story from these different angles would be very complicated, but could have “created a much broader base of understanding and support for issues of sexual harassment” (p. 280). She returns to the idea of chaos in her conclusion stating that people fear “layering multiple and asymmetrical stories will only result in chaos with no women’s history or women’s story to tell” (p. 281). Brown wants us to think past these ideas in order to gain a better understanding of women’s identity that is not explicitly based on gender, but on different experiences.
Response:
I was initially surprised to think that women’s differences were not celebrated within the women’s movement. However, Brown’s logic made it clear that they are not, or that if they are they are only recognized and thus create further walls between what is considered normal and deviant. The case of Anita Hill was interesting in the sense that hypothetically the case could have been treated differently if all of Hill’s identity markers were considered. It could have also potentially opened up the issue of sexual harassment even further. I also really liked Brown’s conclusion that we should be open to change the way we look at women’s history, so that each unique experience can be included. Some people see celebrating differences as detrimental to the women’s movement, but in reality looking at women as normal (white/heterosexual) and deviant (everything else) are much more damaging and limiting.
Monday, September 14, 2009
Week 3: Gayle Rubin: The Traffic in Women Notes on the “Political Economy” of Sex (p. 27-62)
The purpose of this text is to clarify the definition of the sex/gender system. Rubin hopes to define this term by looking at the problem of women’s oppression from a different angle. Meaning, she looks to Freud and Lévi-Strauss for foundations of oppression. She also uses them to define different structures. The sex/gender system is defined in the beginning as occurring when a particular culture turns biological sex into “products of human activity” (p. 28).
Rubin begins her analysis with Marx; however, she states that Marx cannot truly explain women’s oppression because he does not address sex. Basically, Rubin explains Marx by saying that women’s domain became the home because capitalism is an institution inherited by men and women were not given the chance to lead or be in positions of authority.
Next, Rubin analyzes Engels’ The Origin of the Family, Private Property, and the State because he “sees sex oppression as the part of capitalism’s heritage from prior social forms” and “integrates sex and sexuality into his theory of society” (p. 31). Rubin explains that the desires of sexuality and procreation must be fulfilled and that they are not usually satisfied in a natural way. Also, in terms of procreation, every society has a sex/gender system, but the system is changed based on the differing cultures. Rubin clarifies that the sex/gender system is also known as “mode of reproduction” and “patriarchy.” However, the sex/gender system is different because it is a neutral expression that “indicates that oppression is not inevitable…but is the product of the specific social relations which organize it” (p. 33).
Rubin continues her analysis by employing Engel’s method (but not the results) to analyze kinship. She defines kinship as “a system of categories and statuses which often contradict actual genetic relationships” (p. 34). She also notes that kinship varies greatly among cultures. In Mauss’ Essay on the Gift he explains gift giving as an important social interaction. Lévi-Strauss explains further that marriage is a basic form of gift giving, as women are the most precious gift and that the incest taboo is put into place to ensure marriages outside of the family occur and thus the “gifts” that come along with it. Moreover, women cannot truly benefit from this exchange because men are the “giver” and women are the “gift.” So, it is really only an exchange among men and women “do not have full rights to themselves” (p. 39). Rubin argues that this exchange of women was the foundation of each society and it became part of the structure. In terms of kinship, Rubin states: “At the most general level, the social organization of sex rests upon gender, obligatory heterosexuality, and the constraint of female sexuality” (p. 40). On the other hand, she also explains that homosexuality can be established through kinship.
Rubin subsequently examines psychoanalysis and the Freudian perspective. Her goal here is to provide evidence that the psychoanalytic unconscious exists. She explains the “Electra” complex, which is basically the opposite of the Oedipus complex for girls. Moreover, Freud represents femininity as a “consequence of the anatomical differences between the sexes” (p. 44). Meaning that women learn to be passive and feel inferior because of penis envy. Also, the two genders were created to limit the sexual rights of women. Returning to the idea of kinship, it is seen as the learning of sexuality in society where the individual is taught to “play” their biological sex. The idea of the phallus is suggested to be the recognition of the domination of men over women. Finally, Rubin explains that “the oppression of women is deep” and that Lévi-Strauss and Freud serve to outline the structure of women’s oppression (p. 51).
Rubin argues that the sex/gender system is still organized by the theories of Lévi-Strauss and that “in short, feminism must call for a revolution in kinship” (p. 52). She also presents a potential solution to this problem:
“Cultural evolution provides us with the opportunity to seize control of the means of sexuality, reproduction, and socialization, and to make conscious decisions to liberate human sexual life from the archaic relationships which deform it. Ultimately, a thoroughgoing feminist revolution would liberate more than women. It would liberate forms of sexual expression, and it would liberate human personality from the straightjacket of gender” (p. 52).
Overall, she states that the purpose of her essay was to build a theory of women’s oppression by utilizing ideas from anthropology and psychoanalysis. She also hopes to change the sex/gender system through political action.
She concludes this piece by briefly discussing “The Political Economy of Sex” and the ways that the sex/gender system has been historically integrated into society. Again, she highlights the link between marriage and “economic and political arrangements” (p. 56). This also returns to the idea of women as the “gift” in an exchange between men.
Critique/Response:
I found this text to be particularly dense in presenting and relating a lot of different concepts. However, I found the anthropological perspective on the gift giver and the gift to be really interesting. I thought it was the perfect way to explain the idea of marriage. I also liked that it was outlined as another way that women don’t have control of their own bodies. This text really helped me understand how the oppression of women is built into the foundation of all cultures. Although the theories presented were very complex and presented quickly, I felt like the outline of this paper helped frame theory and history for me.
Monday, September 7, 2009
Week 2: Part 3 Introduction (p. 472-477); Guineas and Locks: Virginia Woolf (1882-1941) (p. 622-626); Virginia Woolf: A Room of One’s Own (p. 627-652)
Part 3 Introduction (p. 472-477)
Summary:
The readings from this section of the book are going to shift from moral crusaders to radicals and reformers. There will also be a larger perspective on feminism and class issues. For instance, there will be urban, cosmopolitan, and industrial focuses. These women will also raise questions about social institutions imposing on personal liberties. Another difference in these writings is that they are no longer involved in the church and theology. Finally, there is a shift to focusing on the rights of working class women.
Florence Kelly is given as an example of a feminist that wrote about developing industry and its impact on women and children. She was very concerned for the “human element” (p. 474). Her specialty was legislative reform instead of “political organizer and pamphleteer” (p. 475). She also translated the first English edition of Friedrich Engels’ The Condition of the Working Class in England.
Part three of The Feminist Papers is divided into two perspectives. The first is the radical perspective that critiques the links of marriage and property. This perspective includes the following women: August Bebel, Emma Goldman, and Suzanne La Follette. The second perspective is the reform perspective, which was focused on amelioration and sociologist principles. Texts have been chosen from the following women: Charlotte Gilman, Margaret Sanger, and Jane Addams.
Response/Critique
I am excited to talk about these readings in class this week. Although, they are not completely contemporary I feel that I will be more easily able to relate to the subject matters. Particularly, today I think that the socialist ideology is becoming more important in the U.S. I also believe that women could benefit greatly from a more socialistic perspective in the government. Having just lived in Europe, the improvement in quality of life for everyone is evident. This would just be one more way to level the playing field between men and women. For example, women’s health issues are much more expansive under France’s socialistic government. Also, France is a much more liberal country and I feel that the women have greatly improved rights because of it. The examples that come immediately to mind are child care and the right to an abortion covered by the government health care policy. Women do not have to choose between having a child and a career. The government pays for day care starting at age 2 or 3 and also provides the family a stipend to take care of child expenses. Also, if a woman chooses an abortion, it is not only affordable, but the French use different methods that make the process less traumatic for the woman. Overall, I think that single motherhood would be much more tolerable and comfortable for the mother and child in France.
Guineas and Locks: Virginia Woolf (1882-1941) (p. 622-626)/Virginia Woolf: A Room of One’s Own (p. 627-652)
Summary:
Virginia Woolf published A Room of One’s Own in 1929 after reworking an article entitled “Women and Fiction.” Woolf’s focus was less on political causes and more on her writing. She discussed the difficulties women faced in working creatively: “One was that a young woman must conceal the fact that she ‘had a mind of her own, so that no man should be shocked or offended,’ and the second that there are many things a woman may not freely say about what she physically feels or she will arouse severe masculine disapproval” (p. 622). In Three Guineas she also discussed the social roles of middle-class women, the education of women, professions of women, and women in a war economy (very contemporary).
A Room of One’s Own was written in a very conversational style that allowed Woolf to communicate with and engage the reader. It is very effective because you feel as if you are hearing her voice. She also includes observations about the social roles of men and women. For instance, she provides examples of ridicule and contempt men show towards women and the humiliations that women face in daily interactions. Overall, she argues that women need money (economic independence) and a room of her own (a space to allow contemplation and self reflection).
This excerpt includes texts from chapters two, three, and six of A Room of One’s Own. In chapter two Woolf poses questions directly to the reader and raises important questions. She begins: “Have you any notion how many books are written about women in the course of one year? Have you any notion how many are written by men? Are you aware that you are, perhaps, the most discussed animal in the universe?” (p. 627). She continues to provide examples of how writing represents patriarchy. For example, she discusses the opinions and stories within newspapers. It seems that men control everything, except for the weather in the local news. She continues her explanation that woman’s only purpose seems to be to bolster men’s confidence. Finally, she discusses the importance of money for women. If women are not dependent on men for money, they are freer to express themselves creatively. She argues: “I need not hate any man; he cannot hurt me. I need not flatter any man; he has nothing to give me” (p. 634). Money can represent liberation for women.
In chapter three, Woolf discusses the elevated status of women in fiction versus history or reality. She provides examples, such as, “Clytemnestra, Antigone, Cleopatra, Lady Macbeth, Phèdre, Cressida, Rosalind, Desdemona, and the Duchess of Malfi” (p. 637). She argues that women are viewed here as strong or independent, but historically women did not have the rights that would allow them to make history or even be included in history. At the end of this chapter she discusses the importance for a woman to have her own space or a “room of one’s own.” She also explains that it would be very difficult for most women to attain, but if it were possible, economic freedom and a personal space would better allow woman to thrive creatively and personally.
Finally, in chapter six, Woolf talks about women poets that have lived and died without ever having the chance to become poets. She attests: “She lives in you and in me, and in many other women who are not here to-night, for they are washing up the dishes and putting the children to bed. But she lives; for great poets do not die; they are continuing presences; they need only the opportunity to walk among us in the flesh” (p. 652). She is arguing that with economic freedom and a private space, women could become the great poets, but at this time, it wasn’t always possible to have this luxury.
Response/Critique:
I really enjoyed the last quote from chapter six of A Room of One’s Own. It reminded me of a quote I found last week by Elizabeth and Emily Blackwell. They stated: “For what is done or learned by one class of women becomes, by virtue of their common womanhood, the property of all women” (p. 355). This idea of the woman poet that lives on and the woman doctor that makes way for other women doctors, makes me see how the theme of connectedness and womanhood runs through these articles. The Blackwell sisters and Woolf are urging women to become a part of something larger and lasting.
I also liked the way Woolf explained the status of women in society. Since she did have the two things she thought all women should have (money and personal space) she was able to speak authoritatively on the subject. She presented both types of women, she knew what is was like to not have these things and how her life was greatly improved after obtaining them. Her style also made the reading flow. I felt like she was really talking to me and I think that’s what is great about women writers. You can really feel like a part of the text. Again, I think this contributes to the idea of common womanhood and “the property of all women.” I feel implicated in the writing, and as a result, I feel like I am also contributing to this idea of our property.
Monday, August 31, 2009
Week 1: “‘Remember the Ladies’: Abigail Adams vs. John Adams” (p. 7-15) and “The Blackwell Clan” (p. 323-377)
Summary:
This text includes six letters, four written by Abigail Adams and two written by John Adams. The letters concern Abigail Adams’ desire for women’s rights to be addressed by the Second Continental Congress. The letters are not strictly a dialogue between husband and wife, included are personal letters from Abigail Adams addressing two different friends and a final letter from John Adams to James Sullivan. The letters are presented in a cohesive way that allows us to see Abigail Adams’ argument develop and ultimately be rejected by her husband and fellow politicians.
Abigail Adams begins her first letter detailing her interest in travel, and her inability to do so, based on her sex. It is clear that she is not satisfied with this inequality. The next letter is arguably the most famous and was written approximately five years later by Abigail Adams to John Adams. She recommends that he “Remember the Ladies” (p. 10) while drafting laws for the new country. She also warns that women are likely to start a revolution if they will have no “voice, or Representation” within the new government. John Adams response was that he could not help “but laugh” (p. 11) at the proposition. The following letter from Abigail Adams addresses a friend and she is clearly outraged. She details how she will respond, but in the following letter, which is actually her response to her husband, she appears weak and submissive. The final letter is addressed to James Sullivan by John Adams. He clearly dismisses the whole notion of women’s representation and does not provide a clear or logical response as to why women should be denied this right.
Response/Critique:
I thoroughly enjoyed reading these short letters. I was immediately struck by the seeming independence of Abigail Adams. She began by stating clearly and concisely what she desired. However, her husband’s response upset her, next she planned her rebuttal and then did little to nothing, thus leaving history unchanged for the moment. I was not surprised by John Adams’ response based on the historical timeframe. In the final letter, John Adams writes: “Shall we say that every individual of the community, old and young, male and female, as well as rich and poor, must consent, expressly to every act of legislation? No, you will say, this is impossible” (p. 13). I found this interesting because today it is my understanding that everyone in the U.S. deserves to have their voice heard. For instance, they are not disqualified because of old age or economic status. Declaring something impossible is always easier than actually executing it and I felt like John Adams quickly denied Abigail Adams’ request without giving it any critical thought. He also provides other elusive explanations stating women’s “delicacy renders them unfit for practice and experience in the great business of life” (p. 13) and that women are clearly best suited for domesticity. These statements are not based on fact and I believe that he never really answered the question at hand: Why shouldn’t women be allowed to have the right to vote? I believe that this collection of letters was an appropriate beginning to discuss the eighteenth century and the rights of women as they have progressed throughout history. This was clearly a failure, but it began the dialogue on women’s rights within the United States.
“The Blackwell Clan,” “Elizabeth and Emily Blackwell: Medicine as a Profession for Women,” and “Antoinette Brown Blackwell: Sex and Evolution (p. 323-377)
Summary:
These three texts concern the Blackwell family that lived during the nineteenth century. Many of the members helped further women’s rights in the United States based on the following subjects: “moral reform, abolition, higher education and professional opportunities, political rights” (p. 322). The family originally had nine Blackwell children and later three women married into the family. This first text, “The Blackwell Clan” focuses on the fact that five of the Blackwell women never married. The author presents various perspectives to explain possible emotional problems that led the women into career centered lives. The women made it clear that marriage was not the ultimate satisfaction that they searched for in their lives. However, the Blackwell family was very close-knit and perhaps it was here that the women found the intimacy and friendship necessary to sustain themselves. The men in the family are mentioned, but not as important figures in history. Nevertheless, they introduced Lucy Stone and Antoinette Brown into the Blackwell family. Both women felt strongly about women’s rights, particularly in the domain of academia.
“Elizabeth and Emily Blackwell: Medicine as a Profession for Women” focuses on the need for women to study medicine. Elizabeth and Emily Blackwell can be considered authorities on the subject because they were the first two women to practice medicine with an American medical degree in the United States. They argue that women are invaluable in the field of medicine because there are some medical conditions that only women could relate to or feel comfortable sharing with another woman. They also explain that medicine can be applied to every day life, they state: “Yet the medical profession is at present too far removed from the life of women; they regard these subjects from such a different stand-point that they can not supply the want” (p. 349-350). This suggests that the female perspective was also lacking in medicine. They also propose that women should be teaching medicine. Elizabeth and Emily Blackwell conclude this section by suggesting that women should not be limited to medicine. Women should accordingly be part of all different domains because “For what is done or learned by one class of women becomes, by virtue of their common womanhood, the property of all women” (p. 355). Basically, they are suggesting that by taking varied interests in life and careers, all women will benefit in the end because the next generation can have limitless possibilities.
In the final reading, “Antoinette Brown Blackwell: Sex and Evolution,” the author examines the theory of evolution as presented by Darwin and Spencer. Antoinette Brown Blackwell was the first woman to become an ordained minister in the United States. However, this article is written in a very calculated, scientific style. She disproves points made by Darwin and Spencer with logic and additional facts. She begins her discussion by saying, “Any positive thinker is compelled to see everything in the light of his own convictions” (p.357). Here she is suggesting that Darwin and Spencer are operating from the standpoint of male superiority. Therefore, they had not considered the points she made because they were inclined to find evidence solely in support of their own thinking. She continues her scientific analysis throughout the text. In spite of this, her conclusion returns to the idea of men and women in contemporary society and the institution of marriage. She states: “If Evolution, as applied to sex, teaches any one lesson plainer than another, it is the lesson that the monogamic marriage is the basis of all progress” (p. 376). She continues by explaining that men and women must cooperate and complement one another in order to attain further progress.
Response/Critique:
The first reading surprised me because there was a definite focus on reasons behind the lifestyle chosen by the Blackwell women. I felt like the author focused too much on what was potentially “wrong” with these women instead of presenting them as they were. I understand that mental problems could have potentially defined their personalities, but I felt that the author went too far in some respects to make the point that these women did not choose to be single, there was something inherently wrong with them that then made them choose to be single. I would have preferred to read more about their work and what they did to further women’s rights than speculate as to why they chose not to marry.
The last two readings were interesting because it seemed that Elizabeth and Emily Blackwell traded places with Antoinette Brown Blackwell. Elizabeth and Emily Blackwell discussed the rights of women to pursue a career and made connections specifically to women and medicine. Conversely, Antoinette Brown Blackwell became the first ordained woman minister and she chose to discuss the theory of evolution. If I had to guess before reading, I would have felt that Elizabeth and Emily Blackwell wrote the scientific text and Antoinette Brown Blackwell the more general text on the many capabilities of women. I found the Elizabeth and Emily Blackwell text to be progressive and empowering. Of course, they were arguing for the greater presence of women in medicine, but they did not limit themselves strictly to this field. There was a greater sense that women should strive for more collectively and contribute to the “property of all women” (p. 355). The Antoinette Brown Blackwell text seemed to strictly present the theory of evolution, with the main purpose being to contradict Darwin and Spencer. I preferred the text entitled: “Elizabeth and Emily Blackwell: Medicine as a Profession for Women.” The first text presented many negative aspects about the Blackwell women’s personal lives and the last text read like a scientific article. I felt like this second text by Elizabeth and Emily Blackwell said the most about women being capable of more. I also really enjoyed the positive representation of women and the idea of promoting women to succeed. I feel like this is still important today, but since this was written in the nineteenth century I believe it was very progressive at the time and I enjoyed thinking about the historical mindset when this text was originally published.